Cytosolic Ca2+ buffers bind to a large fraction of Ca2+ as it enters a cell, shaping Ca2+ signals both spatially and temporally. In this way, cytosolic Ca2+ buffers regulate excitation-secretion coupling and short-term plasticity of release. The posterior pituitary is composed of peptidergic nerve terminals, which release oxytocin and vasopressin in response to Ca2+ entry. Secretion of these hormones exhibits a complex dependence on the frequency and pattern of electrical activity, and the role of cytosolic Ca2+ buffers in controlling pituitary Ca2+ signaling is poorly understood. Here, cytosolic Ca2+ buffers were studied with two-photon imaging in patch-clamped nerve terminals of the rat posterior pituitary. Fluorescence of the Ca2+ indicator fluo-8 revealed stepwise increases in free Ca2+ after a series of brief depolarizing pulses in rapid succession. These Ca2+ increments grew larger as free Ca2+ rose to saturate the cytosolic buffers and reduce the availability of Ca2+ binding sites. These titration data revealed two endogenous buffers. All nerve terminals contained a buffer with a Kd of 1.5–4.7 µM, and approximately half contained an additional higher-affinity buffer with a Kd of 340 nM. Western blots identified calretinin and calbindin D28K in the posterior pituitary, and their in vitro binding properties correspond well with our fluorometric analysis. The high-affinity buffer washed out, but at a rate much slower than expected from diffusion; washout of the low-affinity buffer could not be detected. This work has revealed the functional impact of cytosolic Ca2+ buffers in situ in nerve terminals at a new level of detail. The saturation of these cytosolic buffers will amplify Ca2+ signals and may contribute to use-dependent facilitation of release. A difference in the buffer compositions of oxytocin and vasopressin nerve terminals could contribute to the differences in release plasticity of these two hormones.
Excitable cells, such as endocrine cells and neurons, use a sophisticated Ca2+ handling apparatus to control cellular Ca2+ and modulate the impact of Ca2+ signals. Cytosolic Ca2+ buffers are critical components of this apparatus. These proteins bind to ∼99% of Ca2+ within a few milliseconds of entry (Neher, 1995) and control the availability of Ca2+ for diverse signaling functions. In nerve terminals, action potentials open voltage-gated Ca2+ channels to provide the Ca2+ that triggers neurotransmitter release. Ca2+ buffers in nerve terminals play a major role in determining the magnitude and time course of Ca2+ signals and their ultimate efficacy in triggering release (Heinemann et al., 1994; Augustine, 2001; Schneggenburger and Neher, 2005). Depending on their rate of binding, Ca2+ buffers spatially restrict the rise in [Ca2+]Free to a region around the site of entry that can be as small as ∼100 nm (Naraghi and Neher, 1997; Neher, 1998; Wang and Augustine, 2014). In rapid processes such as Ca2+-triggered exocytosis, cytosolic Ca2+ buffers create a complex scenario in which the effect of a Ca2+ signal in triggering release depends on cytosolic buffer properties and the spatial relations between the sources of Ca2+ and sites of action.
In the posterior pituitary, Ca2+ entry triggers the release of the peptide hormones oxytocin and vasopressin from distinct populations of nerve terminals. Secretion is driven by action potentials arriving from the hypothalamus, and the amount of secretion per action potential increases with the frequency and pattern of activity. The dependence of release on activity differs for the two hormones (Poulain and Wakerley, 1982; Gainer et al., 1986). Cytosolic Ca2+ buffers can contribute to the use-dependent facilitation of release because as Ca2+ binding sites saturate the rise in cytosolic free Ca2+ per action potential will increase (Klingauf and Neher, 1997; Blatow et al., 2003; Matveev et al., 2004). The cytosol of posterior pituitary nerve terminals has considerable Ca2+ buffering capacity (Stuenkel, 1994), but the concentrations and affinities of its Ca2+ binding proteins are unknown. As a result, it is not presently possible to estimate how these Ca2+ buffers could influence the facilitation of release.
Most of our present knowledge of cytosolic Ca2+ buffers in situ stems from use of a method introduced by Neher and Augustine (1992), which yields an estimate of the endogenous Ca2+ buffering capacity, κe, defined as the ratio Δ[Ca2+]Total/Δ[Ca2+]Free in the absence of exogenous Ca2+ chelators and fluorescent Ca2+ probes. This approach has been applied to many cell types, yielding κe values in the range of 40–200, with a few anomalous values near 1,000 (Neher, 1995). Although this method has enjoyed widespread use, the quantity κe is of limited value. As [Ca2+]Free rises, Ca2+ binding sites saturate and κe declines. A measurement of a single value for κe therefore provides very limited insight into systems where [Ca2+]Free is dynamically regulated over an appreciable range. The assessment of endogenous Ca2+ buffer saturation requires the measurement of changes in buffering as [Ca2+] rises. Few studies have attempted to analyze saturable Ca2+ binding sites in situ and estimate their Kd and concentration. In cardiac myocytes, Ca2+ buffer saturation permitted the estimation of a concentration and Kd (Berlin et al., 1994). In the axons of dentate gyrus granule cells, increasing [Ca2+]Free from ∼70 nM to ∼1 µM reduced κe from ∼200 to <25 (Jackson and Redman, 2003). Interpreting this concentration dependence of κe in terms of the saturation of a binding site indicated that the endogenous buffer had a Kd of 500 nM and concentration of 130 µM. Therefore, evaluating κe over a range of [Ca2+]Free can be used to characterize Ca2+ buffers in situ. However, this requires separating the buffering by the dye from the buffering by endogenous Ca2+ binding molecules, and dye buffering can often exceed that of the cytosol. We have developed a robust method for the analysis of in situ titration of Ca2+ binding sites. In posterior pituitary nerve terminals this method resolved binding to the different buffering species and enabled us to estimate the Kd of the Ca2+ dye fluo-8 in situ (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). Here we used in situ titration to investigate the cytosolic Ca2+ buffers of these nerve terminals. We resolved two endogenous Ca2+ buffering species, estimated their Kd and concentration, and assessed their mobility. A biochemical analysis revealed calbindin D28K and calretinin, and the in vitro properties of these Ca2+ binding proteins, are consistent with the in situ properties measured here. These endogenous Ca2+ buffers will determine the effectiveness of Ca2+ as a trigger of secretion, and their saturation in physiologic ranges of Ca2+ has the capacity to facilitate release during repetitive activity.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Posterior pituitary slice preparation
Methods follow previous work from this laboratory (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). Male Sprague-Dawley rats (age 6–9 wk) were anesthetized with isoflurane and decapitated following procedures approved by the Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of Wisconsin. The posterior pituitary was removed and immediately placed in ice-cold artificial cerebrospinal fluid consisting of 125 mM NaCl, 4 mM KCl, 1.25 mM NaH2PO4, 26 mM NaHC03, 2 mM CaCl2, and 1 mM MgCl2 bubbled with 95% O2/5% CO2. Acute slices (70 µm) were cut with a VT1200S vibratome (Leica). Slices were stored in artificial cerebrospinal fluid at room temperature until use; all experiments were performed within 4 h.
The posterior pituitary consists primarily of peptidergic nerve terminals with a mean diameter of ∼3 µm and a significant population of larger nerve terminals with diameters >10 µm (Nordmann, 1977). In the present study, we patch clamped large nerve terminals with diameters of 5–15 µm at or near the surface of a slice, located under visual guidance with laser scanning gradient contrast microscopy (Dodt and Zieglgänsberger, 1994; Mainen et al., 1999). Patch-clamp recordings from the larger nerve terminals of this preparation provide estimates of capacitance generally consistent with this size (Bielefeldt et al., 1992; Hsu and Jackson, 1996). Recordings in the whole-terminal configuration were obtained with an Axopatch 200B amplifier and digitized with a Digidata 1322A interface (Molecular Devices). Experimental control and data acquisition were performed with pClamp8 software (Molecular Devices). Slices were perfused with a recording solution consisting of 121 mM NaCl, 4 mM CsCl, 10 mM CaCl2, 1 mM MgCl2, 20 mM tetraethylammonium chloride, 2 mM 4-aminopyridine, 10 mM glucose, 0.003 mM tetrodotoxin, and 10 mM HEPES, pH 7.3. Recordings were performed with an internal patch pipette solution consisting of 130 mM CsCl, 10 mM Na phosphocreatine, 15 mM tetraethylammonium chloride, 4 mM Mg-ATP, 0.3 mM GTP, and 10 mM HEPES, pH 7.3. These solutions were designed to block voltage-gated Na+ and K+ channels to isolate Ca2+ current (ICa; Branchaw et al., 1997). In addition, the internal solution contained 50 or 100 µM of the Ca2+ indicator fluo-8 (Teflabs). Patch pipettes fabricated from borosilicate glass capillaries (King Precision Glass) had resistances of 2–5 MΩ when filled with internal solution. Leak current was corrected with a p/4 subtraction protocol. Data from nerve terminals in which ICa displayed prominent notches or humps suggestive of poor space clamp were discarded.
Frontal cortex, anterior pituitary, and posterior pituitary from 3-mo-old Sprague Dawley rats were homogenized separately with a Dounce homogenizer in 300 µl of lysis buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 150 mM NaCl, and 1% IGEPAL CA-630; I8896; Sigma-Aldrich), with protease inhibitor cocktail (P8340; Sigma-Aldrich) and 1 mM PMSF. The homogenates were sonicated for 5 min on ice and centrifuged at 16,000 g for 20 min in 4°C to collect the supernatant. Protein concentrations were determined by BCA assay and adjusted to 1 µg/µl for all samples. A 15-µl aliquot of each sample was resolved on 15% SDS-PAGE gel, transferred to nitrocellulose membranes, and probed with rabbit anti-calbindin D28K (1:1,000, ab108404; Abcam), rabbit anti-calretinin (1:500, ab92341; Abcam), and rabbit anti-parvalbumin (1:1,000, ab11427; Abcam) antibodies, followed by secondary horse radish peroxidase conjugated antibody, and developed with enhanced chemiluminescence (Pierce Chemicals). The same membrane was then stripped with stripping buffer (1.5% glycine, 0.1% SDS, and 1% Tween 20, pH 2.2) for 15 min at room temperature, probed with mouse anti-actin (1:2,000; Abcam), goat anti-oxytocin (1:1,000, EB09854; Everest), or guinea pig anti–growth hormone antibodies (1:2,000). The experiments were repeated twice.
Ca2+ imaging and two-photon microscopy
Fluorescence images were acquired on a Prairie Ultima two-photon microscope (Bruker) using galvanometer-based scanning. A Chameleon Ti-sapphire laser (Coherent), tuned to 920 nm, delivered <100-fs pulses at ∼80 MHz. Epifluorescent light was collected with a 60×, 0.9 NA water-immersion objective, and transfluorescent light was collected with a 1.4 NA oil-immersion condenser. Collected light was filtered with 525/70-nm bandpass filters and detected with photomultiplier tubes. We used the high dynamic range, visible emission Ca2+ indicator fluo-8. At equilibrium, the fluorescence of such a dye is related to [Ca2+]Free by the following equation (Maravall et al., 2000):(1)where F = f/fmax is the ratio of measured fluorescence to maximal fluorescence when the indicator is saturated with Ca2+; Rf = fmax/fmin is the dynamic range of the indicator. For fluo-8 we estimated an in vitro value for Rf of ∼150 from measurements in 10 mM EGTA and 10 mM CaCl2. The manufacturer states that Rf > 200 , and for values as large as this uncertainties in its magnitude introduce errors in estimates in [Ca2+]Free that are well below the measurement error of f (Maravall et al., 2000). For Kd of fluo-8, we used 390 nM as determined in posterior pituitary nerve terminal cytosol by in situ titration (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). This value equals that determined in vitro.
Dye loading after the establishment of a whole-terminal recording was monitored in real time by resting fluorescence, which stabilized within ∼30–60 s of break-in. Data were collected only after fluorescence had reached this plateau. We have routinely observed that the indicator dye remains in nerve terminals for up to an hour after the termination of a recording, suggesting minimal dye loss by axonal diffusion or leakage. We therefore assumed that the intracellular dye concentration equals that in the pipette.
We acquired fluorescence in line-scan mode at 1 kHz while applying trains of 10–20 voltage steps of 5 ms at 100-ms intervals. This protocol serves as an effective stimulus for Ca2+ entry into pituitary nerve terminals (Jackson et al., 1991; Branchaw et al., 1997) and also approximates physiologic electrical activity of the neurohypophysis (Poulain and Wakerley, 1982). Fig. 1 illustrates a typical experiment. A nerve terminal was loaded with fluo-8, and fluorescence was scanned along the white line indicated in Fig. 1 A (top). Fig. 1 A (bottom) presents fluorescence versus distance along this line at 1-ms intervals over the course of a train of 20 voltage steps (10 Hz) from −80 to 10 mV. Each voltage step opened voltage-gated Ca2+ channels to produce ICa (Fig. 1 C), and fluorescence averaged over the scanned line segment increased in parallel (Fig. 1 B, top). Line scans revealed spatial gradients that collapsed within a few milliseconds, as can be seen in the delayed rise of the fluorescence signal near the center of the nerve terminal (Fig. 2 B). These spatial gradients were generally small compared with the total fluorescence (Fig. 2 C), and after collapse of the gradient, [Ca2+]Free was taken to be spatially uniform. The extrusion of Ca2+ is sufficiently slow, that for many nerve terminals, spatially averaged fluorescence in the intervals between voltage steps remained approximately constant over the brief 100-ms interval between pulses, with no statistically significant time dependence. For these nerve terminals, the mean fluorescence over the interval was used for both the initial fluorescence, FInitial, of the next pulse, and the final fluorescence, FFinal, of the preceding pulse. For other experiments, such as that presented in Fig. 1 B (top), a decline in fluorescence between pulses could be seen. The amount of extrusion was small and the time dependence of F could be well approximated by a linear fit. FInitial and FFinal were estimated from these fits, as illustrated in Fig. 1 B (top).
Toward the end of a stimulus train, fluorescence reached a plateau, which reflected saturation of the dye rather than a [Ca2+]Free steady state (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). We take this limiting value as fmax and use it to determine F (=f/fmax) in the calculation of [Ca2+]Free with Eq. 1. Data from nerve terminals where ΔF for the final stimulus pulse was >1.5% of fmax were discarded on the grounds that fmax may be underestimated. Analysis with a more stringent condition (a cutoff of 0.5% or 1.0%) produced similar results, indicating that the analysis was not sensitive to the precise value of this cutoff. Because of uncertainty in [Ca2+]Free as f approaches fmax (Eq. 1), measurements within two standard errors of fmax were excluded from the model fitting procedure.
Ca2+ buffering model
Simultaneous recordings of F and ICa provide measurement of [Ca2+]Free and the amount of Ca2+ that enters, respectively. With a series of pulses as in Fig. 1, each pulse provides a point in a 3D space with the values of prepulse [Ca2+]Free,Initial, postpulse [Ca2+]Free,Final, and stimulus evoked change in total cytosolic Ca2+ concentration, Δ[Ca2+]Total. These quantities are interrelated through the binding equilibriums of Ca2+ binding sites; therefore, fitting these data to a model for the titration of Ca2+ binding sites can provide estimates of cytosolic buffer properties (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). Using equilibrium binding expressions for Δ[Ca2+]Total in terms of [Ca2+]Free,Initial and [Ca2+]Free,Final, denoted here as Ca1 and Ca2, respectively, the relevant measured quantities in a nerve terminal containing fluo-8 and two endogenous buffers are related by the following expression (McMahon and Jackson, 2014):(2)where [D] is dye concentration and Ca1 and Ca2 are calculated from F using Eq. 1. We obtain Δ[Ca2+]Total by integrating ICa and dividing by terminal volume measured from 3D reconstruction of fluorescence photosections. This volume was multiplied by the fraction that was accessible, and this quantity was treated as a free parameter during the model fitting process. The terms on the right in Eq. 2 represent the change in [Ca2+]Free, the change in Ca2+ dye complex, and the changes in complexes of Ca2+ with two cytosolic buffers. Note that the free parameters relating to endogenous buffers are all in the final two terms. Trains of 10–20 stimuli were applied 10 times at 20-s intervals to yield large 3D datasets with ∼200 points for fitting to Eq. 2. Dropping the final term, e2, provided a model with one cytosolic buffer. To model buffer washout with time, we extended Eq. 2 by multiplying the terms for e1 and/or e2 by an exponential decay factor.
The Ca2+ buffering capacity of Ca2+ binding species i can be calculated as a function of [Ca2+]Free with the following equation (Neher and Augustine, 1992):(3)This equation provides a convenient means of presenting data and for summing the contributions of multiple species.
Data analysis and computational details
Data analysis and model fitting were performed in the statistical computing environment R (R Development Core Team). Results are presented as mean ± SE. The Ca2+ buffering models were fitted by a total least squares procedure, which accounts for errors in the three independent variables measured experimentally. For fits to Eq. 2, [Ca2+]Free was expressed in terms of F so that we fitted to data with normally distributed errors. The data were fitted to two competing models with either one or two endogenous buffers by a custom stochastic gradient descent algorithm, which has been extensively tested and validated with simulated datasets (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). Fits were evaluated with the f test (threshold: P = 0.01), and data were discarded when the P values for any parameter were not significant at the P = 0.01 level (using P = 0.1 or 0.05 for either the f test or parameter significance produced similar results). The computer program Origin 8.0 (OriginLab) was used for some plots and smoothing.
Endogenous buffer saturation
Large posterior pituitary nerve terminals were patch clamped in the whole-terminal configuration using patch pipettes containing the Ca2+ indicator fluo-8 (Fig. 1 A, top), and two-photon imaging enabled us to measure Ca2+. Once dye loading was complete (within 30–60 s of break-in), imaging experiments commenced. Voltage steps opened Ca2+ channels to elicit Ca2+ entry, and applying a series of voltage steps in rapid succession provided a titration curve of the Ca2+ binding molecules in the nerve terminal, including both the Ca2+ dye and endogenous cytosolic Ca2+ buffers. Averaging fluorescence over the scanned line and plotting the spatial mean versus time showed that the fluorescence changes were nearly synchronous with the simultaneously recorded Ca2+ current (ICa; Fig. 1 B, top). With a series of voltage steps, these fluorescence changes became smaller until they were barely visible. In contrast, the changes in [Ca2+]Free computed from these fluorescence changes (Eq. 1, see Materials and methods) grew larger (Fig. 1 B, bottom), even as the Ca2+ entry per pulse, determined from ICa, remained relatively constant (Fig. 1 C). This indicates that Ca2+ binding sites within the nerve terminals saturate with increasing [Ca2+]Free.
The nearly horizontal boundaries in the line scans in Fig. 1 A (bottom) indicated that Ca2+ equilibrated through diffusion and binding within a few milliseconds during and immediately after each voltage step. To illustrate the spatial gradients and their collapse more clearly, a line scan from another nerve terminal focused on the first three voltage steps (Fig. 2). With this timescale, the line scan illustrates the transient spatial gradients more clearly as sags in the boundaries at each voltage pulse (Fig. 2 A). The time course of fluorescence near the edge of the nerve terminal showed rapid increases that began at the start of each voltage pulse and ended when the 5-ms voltage pulse ended (Fig. 2 B). In contrast, the fluorescence at the center increased more slowly with a slight delay. A plot of fluorescence versus position shows roughly uniform fluorescence immediately before the first step (t = 35 ms; Fig. 2 C). A spatial gradient was seen ∼5 ms after the first step (t = 46 ms), and fluorescence became uniform ∼10 ms later (t = 57 ms). Therefore, the spatial and temporal characteristics of the fluorescence changes indicate that the continued increases in spatially averaged fluorescence and [Ca2+]Free immediately after the end of each pulse (Fig. 1 B) reflect spatial equilibration rather than a rapid Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release. This is consistent with the lack of effects of ryanodine and thapsigargin in pituitary nerve terminals (Stuenkel, 1994). These results indicate that binding sites relevant to our titration analysis equilibrate rapidly in space and time and validate our use of a model based on equilibrium binding (Eq. 2). The spatial gradient during a voltage step decays rapidly, and even at its greatest (t = 46 ms; Fig. 2 C), fluorescence varies by <10%. This justifies our use of spatially averaged fluorescence in the calculation of [Ca2+]Free in Eq. 1.
Data of the form presented in Figs. 1 and 2 provided measurements of the Ca2+ concentration before a step, [Ca2+]Free,Initial, the Ca2+ concentration after a step, [Ca2+]Free,Final, and the change in total Ca2+ concentration during a step, Δ[Ca2+]Total (determined by integrating ICa). At equilibrium these quantities will satisfy Eq. 2 (see Materials and methods), and this expression provides a framework for assessing Ca2+ binding interactions with the indicator dye and endogenous buffers. The rapid collapse of spatial gradients seen in Fig. 2 indicates that the equilibrium among the relevant Ca2+ binding sites is reached rapidly. The decays between steps indicate that Ca2+ removal during the interpulse intervals is too slow to be relevant to these binding equilibriums. Fitting our [Ca2+]Free and ICa measurements to this model yielded the concentrations and Kd values of the endogenous buffers. These fits involving three experimental quantities can be displayed with 3D plots, but this form of display is difficult to evaluate visually (McMahon and Jackson, 2014). However, ICa, and therefore Δ[Ca2+]Total, usually remained relatively constant over the course of an experiment (Fig. 1 C). This reduces the dimensionality of the experiment from three to two, and makes it easier to view results. Plots of ΔF versus FInitial illustrate the quality of fits, and plotting F rather than [Ca2+]Free preserves the homoscedasticity of errors, i.e., it gives uniform scatter over the range of values plotted. Fig. 3 A displays data from a nerve terminal where including only one endogenous buffer in Eq. 2 produced a satisfactory fit. Fits to one- and two-buffer models both fell within the scatter of data, yielding visually identical and statistically indistinguishable fits. Fig. 3 B displays another dataset where a two-buffer model (dashed curve) provided a better fit; the one-buffer fit clearly fell outside the scatter of data points, whereas the two-buffer fit fell within this scatter and satisfied our goodness-of-fit criterion.
To illustrate the saturation of endogenous buffers, we calculated the total endogenous Ca2+ buffer capacity, κe, as Δ[Ca2+]Total/Δ[Ca2+]Free minus the dye buffering capacity computed from Eq. 3. These plots show that κe declined as [Ca2+]Free rose (Fig. 4) and provide another visual assessment of the model fits that has the added benefit of displaying the saturation of buffers (at the expense of nonuniform scatter). These plots also permit a comparison of one-buffer and two-buffer fits, where a one-buffer curve was calculated from a single term of Eq. 3 with Kd and [B] from the fit, and a two-buffer curve was calculated as the sum of two such terms. The data in Fig. 4 A were well described by a one-buffer model, and the two-buffer fit was indistinguishable (dashed line). In Fig. 4 B the two-buffer model described the decline in κe over a wide range of [Ca2+]Free, whereas the one-buffer model clearly deviated from the data.
Approximately half our datasets (8 of 17 nerve terminals) were well described by a model containing a single endogenous buffer (as in Figs. 3 A and 4 A), whereas in the other nine nerve terminals a model with two endogenous buffers provided a significant improvement and gave a satisfactory fit (Figs. 3 B and 4 B). Table 1 presents the mean values and standard errors for the concentrations and Kd values of the endogenous buffers determined from these fits, the fraction of excluded volume (a free parameter of the model determined during the fitting), and resting [Ca2+]Free ([Ca2+]Free,0, determined with Eq. 1 from the resting fluorescence). All nerve terminals examined contained a low-affinity buffer. In the one-buffer dataset we found Kd = 1.5 µM and binding site concentration of 170 µM. In the two-buffer dataset we found Kd = 4.7 µM and concentration of 140 µM for the low-affinity buffer. For the high-affinity buffer of this group we found Kd = 0.385 µM and concentration of 340 µM. The mean accessible volume fraction of the single-buffer nerve terminals was slightly higher than that of the two-buffer nerve terminals, but this difference was not statistically significant; the [Ca2+]Free,0 values were essentially the same.
At these resting [Ca2+]Free,0 levels, the one-buffer nerve terminals have a κe value of 57 (Eq. 3). The two-buffer nerve terminals have a total κe of 167, which breaks down to 24 for the low-affinity buffer and 143 for the high-affinity buffer. This suggests that the high-affinity buffer, when present, will have a major impact on Ca2+ rises near rest.
Detection of Ca2+ binding proteins
The nervous system has three major cytosolic Ca2+ buffer proteins, calbindin D28K, calretinin, and parvalbumin (Schwaller, 2010). To assess their expression in the posterior pituitary we performed Western blots of these proteins along with blots for markers of the anterior and posterior lobes of the pituitary. The frontal cortex, which expresses all three Ca2+ binding proteins, was used as a positive control. Both the anterior and posterior pituitary expressed calretinin and calbindin D28K but not parvalbumin (Fig. 5). The signals for both were especially strong in the posterior pituitary. (The slightly weaker band for calretinin in the cortex resembles data available from the manufacturer and does not indicate a low level.) These results suggest that the posterior pituitary has higher levels of calretinin than the cortex, whereas the anterior pituitary has lower levels. (Samples in each lane contained the same total protein, and similar β-actin levels were observed). Pituitary hormones were used as markers and showed the expected pattern of expression, with growth hormone detected in the anterior pituitary and oxytocin detected in the posterior pituitary. We detected no parvalbumin in either the anterior or posterior pituitary, in sharp contrast with the strong signal in the cortex. This experiment demonstrated that the posterior pituitary expresses calbindin D28K and calretinin, but not parvalbumin. Therefore, these two proteins are likely to serve as the endogenous Ca2+ buffers observed in our imaging experiments.
Buffer mobility and washout
Endogenous Ca2+ buffers can be categorized as either fixed or mobile, and this distinction has major functional consequences: mobile buffers accelerate diffusion, and immobile buffers retard diffusion (Sala and Hernández-Cruz, 1990; Zhou and Neher, 1993; Delvendahl et al., 2015). We explored buffer mobility by evaluating the decrease in Ca2+ buffering over time caused by washout during whole-terminal patch-clamp recordings. For this analysis we first focused on recordings from 15 nerve terminals that remained stable for ≥10 min and compared the buffering capacity determined shortly after break-in with the buffering capacity determined 10 min later. This group included some experiments for which fits to Eq. 2 failed and did not include those nerve terminals yielding satisfactory fits to Eq. 2 (Figs. 3 and 4) that lasted <10 min. To determine κe for this group of 15 without fitting to Eq. 2, we used a model-independent method in which Δ[Ca2+]Total was divided by Δ[Ca2+]Free, and the dye buffering capacity, κd, was calculated from Eq. 3 (κe in Fig. 4 was calculated this way as well). κe determined in this way declined by 37%, and the exponential decay time calculated from the 0- and 10-min time points was 1,300 ± 210 s. There was no significant difference between the decline in κe between one-buffer and two-buffer nerve terminals. However, the 15 terminals used in this comparison included only three one-buffer nerve terminals. For reasons that are unclear, recordings from one-buffer terminals appeared to be less stable.
Fig. 6 presents an especially clear example of buffer washout from a nerve terminal. κe, determined as just described above and for Fig. 4 (from Δ[Ca2+]Total, Δ[Ca2+]Free, and κd), was plotted versus [Ca2+]Free. The plot from data obtained ∼10 min after break-in (Fig. 6, open triangles) fell well below the earlier plot obtained from the first train of pulses applied shortly after fluorescence stabilization (∼30 s after break-in; Fig. 6, open circles). This difference was observed over the entire range of [Ca2+]Free. Although the fractional change in κe appears greater at high [Ca2+]Free, analysis described in the next paragraph supports a general conclusion of washout of the high-affinity component, with no statistically significant loss of the low-affinity component.
We also evaluated buffer washout using a modification of the model represented by Eq. 2. We multiplied the concentration of buffer species e1, [Be1], by an exponential decay factor of the form e−t/τ. t represents time after break-in, and τ represents the time constant of washout of buffer species e1. This model was then fitted to data from 20 trains of voltage steps collected over 5–6 min of recording. This fit involved varying the parameters of Eq. 2, as well as τ. None of the eight single-buffer nerve terminals (Table 1, top row) showed a statistically significant decay in buffering capacity; 1/τ (the rate of buffer washout) was indistinguishable from zero in all cases. Of the nine two-buffer nerve terminals (Table 1, bottom row), the fits to four were improved by including the exponential washout factor, whereas fits to the other five showed no improvement. The rate of washout is inversely proportional to cell volume (Pusch and Neher, 1988), and it is noteworthy that the four nerve terminals yielding a significant value for τ had a mean volume of 900 ± 300 µm3, whereas the five two-buffer nerve terminals not yielding a τ value had a mean volume of 1,800 ± 270 µm3. The eight one-buffer nerve terminals, none of which yielded a τ value, also had larger volumes of 1,700 ± 600 µm3.
We also modified our mobile buffer model by multiplying both [Be1] and [Be2] of the two buffers of Eq. 2 by the same exponential factor and fitted this version to the data from the eight two-buffer nerve terminals. This enabled us to test the hypothesis that both buffers washed out at the same rate. Bootstrap resampling indicated that in no instance did this model improve the fits compared with a model where only one of the two buffers was mobile. Overall, the results of these fits to extended models with mobile buffers indicate that the high-affinity buffer is mobile and that the low-affinity buffer is not sufficiently mobile to produce detectable washout.
Fits to our extended model with one mobile species yielded properties for the two buffers presented in Table 2. These values are similar to those from the aforementioned two-buffer fits for model fitting with no washout (Table 1, bottom row). The mobile buffer in these experiments declined with a time constant of τ = 243 ± 56 s. To compare τ values across nerve terminals, one must take into account the dependence of washout on cell volume and access resistance (Pusch and Neher, 1988). Taking each τ value and factoring in the values of series resistance and volume from that nerve terminal, Eqs. 17 and 18 from Pusch and Neher (1988) gave a diffusion constant, D = 12 ± 1 µm2/s from the 10-min decline measurements of 15 nerve terminals and 14 ± 3 µm2/s for the four extended model fits where significant washout was seen. (Note that the D values have smaller errors than the τ values because the volumes and access resistances contribute to the variability in τ.) Based on the Stokes–Einstein equation, these D values correspond to apparent molecular weights of 1.3 and 0.9 MD, respectively.
In this study, we characterized the properties of distinct molecular species that contribute to the complex dynamics of Ca2+ signaling in posterior pituitary nerve terminals. The increase in step size of [Ca2+]Free during depolarizing trains (Fig. 1, B [top] and C) served as the critical observation that enabled us to go beyond the standard determination of concentration independent κe values. Therefore, we were able to use a saturable titration model to determined Kd and concentration and take the additional step of resolving two endogenous Ca2+ binding species. This analysis provided an assessment of cytosolic Ca2+ buffer properties directly from a study of their functional impact on cellular Ca2+ signals. All nerve terminals contained a relatively immobile low-affinity buffer, and approximately half contained an additional weakly mobile high-affinity buffer. The Ca2+ binding proteins present in the cytoplasm of pituitary nerve terminals will determine the action of Ca2+ on the secretion apparatus, and their saturation will modify these responses over time during repetitive activity.
Endogenous Ca2+ buffers
Our analysis revealed the presence of two endogenous Ca2+ buffers, but not in all nerve terminals. Nerve terminals fell into two categories, one with both a high-affinity and low-affinity buffer and another with only a low-affinity buffer. In both populations Ca2+ buffering at rest was comparable with that observed in other preparations, with κe falling within the range of previous observations of ∼40–200 (Neher, 1995). A previous study of Ca2+ buffering in dissociated pituitary nerve terminals determined κe to be ∼175 (Stuenkel, 1994). This value is somewhat greater than our estimate of resting κe = 124 for two-buffer terminals and substantially greater than our estimate of κe = 57 for one-buffer terminals. These differences most likely reflect a lower resting [Ca2+]Free in the experiments of the previous study (Stuenkel, 1994), which would make more Ca2+ binding sites available.
Roughly half the pituitary nerve terminals contain high-affinity buffer, with a Kd of 385 nM and concentration of 340 µM. All nerve terminals contain a lower-affinity buffer with a higher Kd of 1.5–4.7 µM and concentration of 140–170 µM (Table 1). Our Western blots revealed the presence of both calretinin and calbindin D28K in the posterior pituitary. The high-affinity component is consistent with the ∼200–500 nM in vitro Kd range for calbindin D28K. The Kd of our one-buffer terminals was the same as the ∼1.5 µM in vitro Kd of calretinin (Schwaller, 2010; Alpár et al., 2012), but the low-affinity component of our two-buffer terminals had a higher Kd of 4.7 µM. Overall, our biochemical detection of calbindin D28K and calretinin (Fig. 5) is consistent with our fluorometric titration results. An earlier and simpler version of this titration method identified a cytosolic buffer in hippocampal granule cell axons with properties close to the known cytosolic buffer of these neurons, calbindin D28K (Jackson and Redman, 2003), and subsequent immunocytochemical analysis confirmed our fluorometric estimate of the concentration of this species (Müller et al., 2005). The concentrations of cytosolic buffer proteins determined here in nerve terminal cytoplasm in Table 1 can be converted to protein concentrations by dividing by four functional Ca2+ binding sites for calbindin D28K and five for calretinin (Schwaller, 2010). These multiple binding sites on each protein do not differ widely in affinity, and single-site noncooperative binding models used here adequately approximate their collective impact on the saturation of Ca2+ signals.
Although our in situ Kd values are close to published in vitro values, such comparisons must recognize the following: (1) cytosolic Ca2+ buffers can have multiple nonequivalent sites and cooperative binding; (2) Mg2+ competes with some Ca2+ binding sites to varying degrees; and (3) the cytosolic environment can alter affinities, as seen with organic chelators (Thomas et al., 2000; Hagen et al., 2012). Indeed, these considerations underscore the need for studies of cytosolic buffers in situ as conducted here. Our fluorometric analysis is consistent with the absence of parvalbumin in Western blots because parvalbumin has a much lower Kd than the high-affinity component determined here. The rapid equilibration seen in our line scans is also consistent with the absence of parvalbumin because parvalbumin equilibrates slowly (Lee at al., 2000). In any case, at the relatively high resting [Ca2+]Free,0 of pituitary nerve terminals, parvalbumin would be largely saturated.
The nerve terminals of the posterior pituitary are heterogeneous, with half releasing oxytocin and half releasing vasopressin. Our results suggest that cytosolic buffer content is also heterogeneous. Posterior pituitary nerve terminals have also been distinguished on the basis of volume, electrophysiologic properties, and presence of other neuropeptides (Bondy et al., 1989; OuYang et al., 2004). The nerve terminals with only low-affinity buffer had a mean volume of 1,730 ± 570 µm3, compared with 1,390 ± 230 µm3 for terminals with both buffer components; however, this difference was not statistically significant.
In addition to Ca2+ binding proteins, cytoplasm contains several other Ca2+ binding molecules, including small molecules such as ATP (Baylor and Hollingworth, 1998), Ca2+ signaling proteins such as calmodulin, and polar phospholipids. ATP is present at high concentrations and has fast binding kinetics, but its low affinity would make its contribution negligible even at millimolar concentrations (as is readily shown with Eq. 3). Other Ca2+ binding molecules, presumably with a range of affinities, could contribute to saturable buffering, and our Kd estimates could reflect some aggregate behavior. Such aggregate effects may account at least in part for the higher Kd of the low-affinity component (Table 1) compared with the in vitro Kd of calretinin.
Endogenous Ca2+ buffers washed out of nerve terminals during whole-terminal patch clamp recording, but very slowly. Although a previous study of pituitary terminals suggested that κe was stable for 5 min (Stuenkel, 1994), the lower bound to the mass of the buffer estimated in that study of 125 kD, determined by the same equations we used (Pusch and Neher, 1988), was well below our estimate of ∼1 MD; therefore, there is no real disagreement. In the present study we were able to observe buffer washout because of longer recording times and more sensitive instrumentation (smaller volumes and lower series resistances may also be significant factors). The expected M1/3 dependence of the diffusion constant on molecular weight of a globular protein suggests that the washout we observed is ∼3.2-fold slower than that expected for calbindin D28K (28 kD) and calretinin (31 kD). If these proteins were completely free to diffuse, the washout would have been observable in our experiments, especially in nerve terminals with larger volumes. This suggests that posterior pituitary nerve terminals have little if any freely diffusing buffer.
The slow washout indicates that essentially all of the endogenous buffer interacts with cytoskeleton and intracellular membrane to impede diffusion. The factor of approximately three reduction in washout time can most easily be interpreted in terms of a loose tethering in which approximately one third of the protein is free, and the free and bound fractions equilibrate in under ∼1 min. The clear association of washout with the high-affinity component in our extended fits suggests that the high-affinity buffer, presumably calbindin D28K, is more mobile than the low-affinity buffer, presumably calretinin. Reduced mobility is consistent with our failure to detect parvalbumin. This protein has a very low molecular weight (12 kD) and no known binding partners or signaling functions (Schwaller, 2010); therefore, it is not likely to be tethered. Both calbindin D28K and calretinin display significant conformational changes on Ca2+ binding and have known binding partners (Schwaller, 2010). Calbindin D28K is immobile in cerebellar axons (Schmidt et al., 2005), and calretinin exhibits anomalously slow diffusion in cerebellar neurons (Arendt et al., 2013). The very slow washout of endogenous buffer in our experiments is consistent with these results. Several secretory cell types have immobile endogenous buffers with much lower affinities than those observed in the present study, but the molecular identity of these Ca2+ binding sites has not been established (Xu et al., 1997; Habets and Borst, 2006; Matthews et al., 2013; Delvendahl et al., 2015; Nakamura et al., 2015).
Implications for facilitation
High-frequency electrical stimulation facilitates neurotransmitter release from many nerve terminals (Zucker and Regehr, 2002), including those of the posterior pituitary (Poulain and Wakerley, 1982; Gainer et al., 1986). Theoretical and computational investigations of presynaptic Ca2+ suggest that buffering can contribute to this form of short-term plasticity (Klingauf and Neher, 1997; Matveev et al., 2004). Paired-pulse facilitation can be induced at normally nonfacilitating synapses by exogenous chelator (Rozov et al., 2001), and saturation of calbindin D28K underlies paired-pulse facilitation in multipolar bursting cells and mossy fiber terminals (Blatow et al., 2003). The saturation of endogenous Ca2+ buffers described here will amplify presynaptic Ca2+ signals during repetitive activity and therefore contribute to the frequency-dependent facilitation of release from the posterior pituitary. This mechanism would then be additive with action potential broadening (Gainer et al., 1986; Bourque, 1990; Jackson et al., 1991) and Ca2+-dependent nitric oxide synthase-mediated reduction in action potential failure (Klyachko et al., 2001; Zhang et al., 2007).
Calbindin D28K is already partly saturated at [Ca2+]Free,0 and will amplify stimulus-induced Ca2+ increases as soon as they start, but calretinin with its higher Kd will have its impact at higher levels of [Ca2+]Free where mitochondrial sequestration also comes into play (Stuenkel, 1994; Kosterin et al., 2005). The heterogeneity of pituitary nerve terminals mentioned earlier in the Discussion includes differences in the frequency dependence and optimal patterns of activity that elicit vasopressin and oxytocin release (Poulain and Wakerley, 1982; Gainer et al., 1986; Cazalis et al., 1987; Bicknell, 1988). If the heterogeneity in Ca2+ buffers reported here is associated with neuropeptide content, this could underlie some of the differences in secretion behavior. Two populations of nerve terminals with different cytosolic Ca2+ buffers will define distinct ranges of [Ca2+]Free over which buffer saturation will amplify Ca2+ signals.
We thank Peter Bayguinov and Elizabeth Matthews for helpful discussions and comments on the manuscript.
This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health grants NS44057 and NS72905.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Kenton J. Swartz served as editor.
- Submitted: 8 October 2015
- Accepted: 6 January 2016
This article is distributed under the terms of an Attribution–Noncommercial–Share Alike–No Mirror Sites license for the first six months after the publication date (see http://www.rupress.org/terms). After six months it is available under a Creative Commons License (Attribution–Noncommercial–Share Alike 3.0 Unported license, as described at http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/).